This was our 3rd straight year vacationing on Martha's Vineyard in the Fall. This year, we were not able to stay in the B&B we enjoyed last year, so I started researching rental houses, etc. I was lucky enough to find a small rental in the East Chop area of the Island for a great price for a week. We were not staying for an entire week, but the price was cheaper than we would have paid for 3-4 days at the B&B. We were somewhat skeptical, but we communicated with the owner several times, and we finally pulled the trigger.
We were very glad we did. We had a small apartment that sat above a large garage on a property that overlooked the Nantucket Sound and the East Chop Lighthouse.


It was amazing and very private. We had to get to and from town on bikes that we rented, which was great.
The houses around us were mostly empty, as it was late in the season. Fortunately, the weather was perfect. We have gone to MV in late September for the last 3 years, and we are 2 for 3 with the weather. In '08 we had cold and rain. We got to spend a lot of time relaxing.
I was able to try some fishing (no luck), while April spent time shopping and reading. We had to go to The Net Result in Vineyard Haven (our rental was between Oak Bluffs and Vineyard Haven) to get a lobster roll.
The lobster rolls here are amazing. Imagine, the freshest lobster possible tossed lightly with basically mayo, salt and pepper. Ridiculous, really. Oddly enough, we have also found some amazing pizza on the Island in Oak Bluffs at Giordano's. They have a take out window open late in the season, and they sell pizza by the slice there. It really is some of the best NY style pizza I have had.
One of the coolest things about the rental we had was the outside shower. We were freaked out by this in the beginning, but once we took a shower in the outside stall, we were hooked. It was so refreshing to be taking a hot shower outside in the morning with temps around 50 degrees.
This island is a special place.